I loved the drama version of this. It was one of the very first Jdoramas I watched that had quite an impact on me. So I can't help but compare the two. They were executed differently, actually there were some important stuff that the movie missed to show. But I don't really know what really transpired so I can't say which one was closer to the real thing. If I had to believe in one, I'd like to believe the drama cuz it includes a detailed account of Aya's love life. I think that, and a good scoring, is the drama's advantage over the movie.
Rating:
Story:
Interest: 2
(2 = I love it, 1.5 = I like it, 1 = It's okay, 0 = I didn't like it)
Coherence: 2
(2 = Well stitched story, 1 = There are a lot of missing links, 0 = What was the story about?)
Reality: 2
(2 = True-to-life, felt like it was real or it could really happen, 0 = How could something like that happen in real life?)
Inspiration: 2
(2 = Inspiring, 0 = No lessons learned)
Movie:
Execution: 1
(2 = It feels so real, 1 = Some parts feel real while some don't, 0 = It sucks)
Effect: 1
(2 = Made me cry/laugh/feel warm/angry or touched me for at least 75% of the movie, 1 = Managed to make me cry or laugh at least once, 0 = I felt nothing)
Acting: 1
(2 = The actors were completely lost in their characters, 1 = Some were good while some were annoying, 0 = The story was good but the actors really sucked)
Casting: 1
(2 = There's no other actor fit for the lead role, 1 = The acting is good but something feels off, 0 = Poor cast)
Compactness: 1
(2 = Didn't blink even once, 1.5 = Skipped some parts but didn't blink on some, 1 = Skipped more than watched)
Cinematography: 1
(2 = Love it, 1.5 = Like it, 1 = Just okay, 0 = It sucks)
Scoring: 1
(2 = Helps in bringing out the viewer's emotions/ I love the soundtrack, 1.5 = The scoring matches the scenes, 1 = At least the movie has a soundtrack, 0 = The movie doesn't have one.)
Recommend? 1
(2 = Highly recommended, 1 = Recommended to a chosen few, 0 = Don't waste your time on this)
- For those who'd like to watch this movie, I think it'd be better to watch the drama instead. The drama's a whole lot better cuz it runs longer so the scenes develop slower, making the story feel more complete. The movie showed the whole story but it still feels incomplete. And I loved the soundtrack of the drama.
Total Rating: 3.3/5
Sorry for the inconvenience
This blog is best viewed in Mozilla Firefox.
Tuesday, August 17, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment